Key Takeaways
-
Both nasal dilators and nasal strips help keep the nasal valve open. Nasal dilators do this from inside your nose, while strips lift the sides of your nose from the outside.
-
Nasal dilators can be a good option for frequent nasal snoring, especially if you have skin irritation from adhesives. In a 2019 clinical study, they helped more snorers than strips, and they are reusable with no adhesive.
-
Nasal strips can be more convenient for exercise, occasional stuffy noses, and are a good option for anyone who doesn’t like putting anything in their nose. They also don’t need to be washed daily to maintain hygiene.
-
For sport, sensitive noses, and short-term congestion, nasal strips are generally easier and come in sweat-proof options.
-
Neither option will straighten a deviated septum or treat sleep apnea. If you snore and also have gasping, breathing pauses, or feel sleepy during the day, see a doctor first.
Comparing a nasal dilator vs nasal strips after one hasn’t worked? An internal nasal dilator is worth trying for recurring nasal snoring, a narrow valve, and adhesive reactions. Nasal strips are usually easier for sports, sensitive nostrils, or occasional stuffiness.
This guide explains how both options work, compares the evidence and costs, and offers tips to help you get started and use them correctly.
What Are Nasal Dilators?
Nasal dilators are small devices, usually made from medical-grade plastic or silicone, designed to fit into the nostrils to reduce snoring and improve airflow.
They are also sometimes known as nasal stents and are commonly used by individuals with nasal obstructions, such as deviated septums or congestion due to chronic allergies or infections.
Nasal dilators are discreet and come in various sizes and designs to suit different preferences, offering an easy, affordable solution for those seeking relief from nasal breathing difficulties.
What Are Nasal Strips?
Nasal strips are small adhesive strips that are applied to the outside of the nose to help improve airflow through the nasal passages.
This non-invasive method could reduce snoring and improve sleep quality for some users. Using nasal strips is a popular practice among athletes to enhance air intake during exercise.
They are also commonly used by individuals seeking a drug-free alternative to relieve nasal congestion from colds and allergies and to promote better breathing at night.
How Nasal Dilators and Nasal Strips Open Your Nose
Both devices help open the nasal valve, the narrowest part of your nasal airway where airflow can easily be restricted or blocked.
A nasal dilator is a small cone, ring, or clip made of flexible material. You place it inside your nostrils to support the nasal walls.
A nasal strip, also known as an external nasal dilator, sticks across your nose. Its flexible bands have a spring-like action that gently lifts the sides of your nose outward.
Both can make it easier to breathe through your nose while you wear them. However, they do not prevent your tongue or throat tissues from collapsing during sleep, which can sometimes cause breathing issues.
You can find more details in our guides on how do nasal strips work to relieve snoring and do nasal dilators really work?
Nasal Dilator vs Nasal Strips: Key Differences at a Glance
The main difference between nasal dilators vs nasal strips, is that you clean and reuse an insert, while you throw away an adhesive strip after each use.
|
Feature |
Nasal dilator (internal) |
Nasal strip (external) |
|
Where it sits |
Inside the nostrils |
Across the outside of the nose |
|
Reusable |
Usually, although lifespan varies by product |
No |
|
Adhesive on skin |
None |
Yes |
|
Cost per night |
Depends on price and how long the product is reusable for |
Usually around $0.50-$1 per night |
|
First-night comfort |
May take some adjusting |
No adjustment period |
|
Visibility |
Almost invisible |
Visible across the nose. Level of visibility depends on the width and color |
|
Sport and sweat |
Safe for sport and sweating, however, they may fall out if they don’t fit well |
Sweat-resistant options are available |
|
Deviated septum/valve collapse |
Can help to open the nasal valve but can’t fix a deviated septum |
Can help to open the nasal valve but can’t fix a deviated septum |
|
Evidence for snoring |
A study showed positive results in more than 41 snorers |
A study found that nasal strips significantly reduced snoring frequency in people with chronic rhinitis |
|
Hygiene |
Can be harder to keep clean. Daily washing of the device is needed to prevent the build-up of bacteria |
Fresh strips pose no hygiene concerns, however, clean and dry skin is needed for optimal adhesion |
What the studies actually found:
-
A randomised controlled study found that nasal strips significantly reduced snoring frequency in people with chronic rhinitis compared with placebo strips. (1)
-
A small study compared a nasal dilator with Breathe Right® strips in 41 snorers, both reduced snoring time, but the internal device helped more participants and was associated with better sleep quality. This was a small, open study, so it cannot establish a universal winner. (2)
-
A 2016 Camacho meta-analysis found no significant overall improvement in snoring index or apnea-hypopnea index (AHI) with nasal dilators or strips in those with obstructive sleep apnea. Internal devices showed a reduction in apnea index of 4.87 events/hour versus a 0.64 increase with external strips, but neither change was statistically significant. (3)
Key Benefits of Nasal Dilators
Internal dilators provide reusable support without using adhesive on your skin. This can make them a good choice for regular use, especially if strips have been uncomfortable for you, but some people might find them too invasive.
Reusable, With Nothing Stuck to Your Skin
An internal dilator doesn’t require any adhesive, which can help you avoid skin reactions and the repeated peeling that can make strips cause discomfort. If you keep having problems with nasal strips, even when choosing hypoallergenic options, it may be time to try a nasal dilator instead.
They are also reusable, which can save you money each night, but how long each one lasts depends on the brand. You usually can’t expect a single device to last for months.
Look at the cost for each use, not just the price of the device.
A Stronger Hold on the Nasal Valve
An internal dilator supports your nasal walls from the inside, so it does not rely on adhesive sticking to your skin. If a strip comes loose or feels too weak, a properly fitted nasal dilator might give you steadier support.
In the 2019 study of 41 snorers, both nasal strips and dilators reduced snoring time, while the internal dilator improved reported sleep quality more. (2)
This suggests you should try an insert if strips have not worked well for you. However, it does not mean every nasal dilator is always better than every nasal strip. The design and fit will still affect your results.
Better for Deviated Septum and Chronic Blockage
An dilator might be a better option if you have an ongoing blockage due to narrowing or nasal valve collapse, especially if strips have not helped significantly.
While neither device straightens a deviated septum, both can address a valve problem, and ENT guidance includes dilators and strips as options to facilitate easier breathing.
If your nose is chronically blocked, an ENT can identify what is restricting airflow.
Adjustable Fit
Some internal nasal dilators are available in different sizes, and some let you adjust each side separately. This flexibility can help if your nostrils feel different or if one side needs a better fit.
Mute, for example, offers small, medium, and large sizes with adjustable paddles. A starter pack lets you compare sizes before buying several of the same one. Follow the manufacturer’s fitting instructions rather than choosing the largest insert you can tolerate. Read more in our full Mute Nasal Dilator Review.
A good fit should feel secure and help you breathe more easily, without causing pressure or pain. If the device keeps slipping out or feels uncomfortable, try a different size or design.
Our roundup of the best nasal dilators for snoring compares designs you may want to consider.
Less Visible During Wear
Most of a nasal dilator stays inside your nostrils, with only a small bridge at the bottom showing. If you do not like how a strip looks on your nose, an insert might be a more discreet choice.
This is more about personal preference than airflow. Some people don’t mind the look of a strip, while others prefer something less noticeable, especially if you’re going to use it during the day.
Comfort is most important. A less visible device only helps if it fits well and stays put. Try it while you are awake before sleeping with it, and make sure you can put it in and take it out easily.
Where Nasal Dilators Fall Short
-
Adjustment period: A nasal dilator can feel unfamiliar or uncomfortable for the first few nights.
-
Fit matters: The wrong size can press against nasal tissue or slip out during heavy breathing. Stop if it causes soreness or bleeding.
-
Regular cleaning: Wash and dry reusable devices after each use as directed, and never share them with someone else.
-
Replacement costs: Reusable devices still need to be replaced on schedule, even when they look intact. Our Airmax Nasal Dilator Review covers one popular option.
Key Benefits of Nasal Strips
Nasal strips are an easy way to help you breathe through your nose from the outside without the need for invasive inserts. They are convenient for exercise, occasional stuffiness, and for people who do not like putting things inside their nose.
Easiest to Use, Nothing Inside Your Nose
A nasal strip is a simple choice if you do not like the idea or feel of an insert. Just peel off the backing, place the strip across your nose, and press it down. You do not have to put anything inside your nose or clean it afterward.
You still need to place the strip correctly and choose one that fits your nose. If you put it too high, it may not open your nasal valve enough. Damp or oily skin can also make it less sticky.
Our guide on how to apply nasal strips provides more details on preparation and placement in order to get the best results. Once you have that right, application is a quick step before bed or exercise.
Better for Sport and Sweat
A sweat-resistant nasal strip is handy for exercise, and its slim shape usually fits with sports gear, as long as goggles or sunglasses do not rub against it.
Dream Recovery Second Wind Nasal Strips offer sweat-proof grip and a hypoallergenic adhesive that many athletes love (check out our guide to the best nasal strips for athletes).
A 2022 review reported encouraging findings for oxygen uptake and perceived effort, although the evidence remains uncertain, and a 2020 meta-analysis found no improvement in VO2max, heart rate, or perceived exertion in healthy exercisers. So, while it’s uncertain whether nasal strips will improve your performance, more comfortable nasal breathing is the main reason to try them during exercise. (4) (5)
Shop Second Wind Nasal Strips to optimize your workouts and sleep.
Gentle Short-Term Relief for Colds and Allergies
A strip gives you drug-free support without touching the inside of your nose. This can be helpful if your nostrils feel sore from a cold or allergies. You can use it with saline spray, but it will not remove mucus or treat swelling.
While plenty of anecdotal reports demonstrate improvements in congestion, results may vary. In two 2019 studies involving 270 people, both the nasal strip and placebo groups reported improvements, with no significant difference between them after 14 nights. The research focused on persistent nighttime congestion, so it doesn’t tell us how well strips work during a short cold. (6)
Our guide to nasal strips for a stuffy nose explains in more detail when they may help.
No Cleaning Routine
With a nasal strip, you do not have to wash, rinse, dry, or store anything. Just put a new strip on clean skin and throw it away after use. This makes it easy to use, even when you are tired or traveling.
Nasal strips are also a good choice if you know you will not regularly clean an internal device. A simpler routine can help you use your breathing aid as recommended.
Do not try to reuse nasal strips and always follow the instructions for each one.
Where Nasal Strips Fall Short
-
Adhesive irritation: Strips can cause redness or irritation, even when labeled hypoallergenic. Avoid broken skin and remove them gently with warm water.
-
Single-use cost: Each wear adds to ongoing spending.
-
Peeling edges: If your skin is oily or damp, the strip may not stick well and could lift off during sleep or exercise.
-
Placement matters: If you put the strip too high on your nose, it may not open your nasal valve enough.
-
Structural limitations: Significant blockages may persist even when used correctly.
Take a look at our guide to the best nasal strips for a deviated septum.
Nasal Dilator vs Nasal Strips: Which Is Better for You?
Pick the option that fits your main issue and what you will actually use. These are practical ways to start, but they do not prove that one type is always better than the other.
For Running, Training and Sport
Choose a sweat-proof nasal strip if you want an easy, external option for workouts. It keeps the inside of your nostrils free and does not need to be cleaned after exercise.
Put the strip on before you start sweating to ensure the adhesive sets properly. Try it during a regular workout before using it in a race. If you cannot use adhesive on your skin, an internal sports dilator is another option, so consider a nasal strip alternative.
Pick what feels most comfortable and stable. Our comparison guide to the best nasal strips for athletes explains what to look for.
For Sensitive Skin or Adhesive Reactions
Choose an internal dilator if your skin reacts to adhesive or to the process of removing strips. This avoids skin contact completely to minimize irritation.
However, sensitive skin and sensitive nasal tissue are two different issues. If an insert hurts the inside of your nostrils, a hypoallergenic strip might actually feel better and be more comfortable.
Hypoallergenic strips can still cause irritation. Do not use them on broken or sore skin, take them off gently, and stop using them if you get a rash. Our guide on nasal strip side effects has tips to help reduce irritation.
For Snoring Every Night
Try an internal dilator first if a nasal blockage is causing you to snore every night. Since it is reusable, it works well for regular use.
Pay attention to both comfort and whether your snoring improves. Easier nasal breathing does not always mean you will sleep more quietly if the blockage is farther back in your airway.
If you snore and also gasp, stop breathing at night, or feel sleepy during the day, you should see a doctor. If you snore with your mouth open, mouth tape might be a better option (if you can breathe comfortably through your nose).
Learn more about mouth tape vs nasal strips here.
For a Deviated Septum or Chronic Blockage
Try an internal dilator if your blockage is due to a narrow nasal valve, and see an ENT doctor if your symptoms don’t improve. A nasal dilator might help if strips have not worked well enough.
A deviated septum is a structural problem that neither device can fix, although they can make breathing feel easier. Do not force an insert into a nostril that is very narrow or painful. If neither option helps, focus on finding the cause rather than buying different devices.
Take a look at the best nasal strips for a deviated septum.
For a Cold, Allergies or Occasional Congestion
Try a nasal strip for a quick solution, especially if the inside of your nose is sore, swollen, or irritated. It can help open your nasal passages to improve airflow right away.
A nasal strip can work alongside saline spray to help ease occasional stuffiness. Saline helps loosen mucus, while the strip gently lifts the sides of your nose to create more room for airflow. If allergies are contributing to congestion, treatment that reduces inflammation may also help.
Our guide “do nasal strips for a stuffy nose & congestion?” explains what they can and cannot do.
For Sleep Apnea
Do not use either option as a treatment for sleep apnea. A 2016 meta-analysis found no meaningful improvement in outcomes for obstructive sleep apnea. (7)
While either device might help you breathe through your nose more easily along with your prescribed treatment, do not use them instead of CPAP or other recommended care.
If you snore loudly, wake up gasping, or feel very sleepy during the day, get checked by a doctor first. Our guide on do nasal strips treat sleep apnea explains why better nasal airflow does not mean your apnea is treated.
How to Apply a Nasal Strip and Nasal Dilator Properly
Correct placement helps both devices work comfortably. Follow the instructions for your specific product, as wear time and fitting methods can vary between different brands.
Nasal Strips
Preparing your skin and putting the strip in the right place are essential for its durability and efficacy. Here are the key steps to follow:
-
Clean and dry: Wash your nose and dry it completely. Do not put lotion or any other skincare products underneath.
-
Position: Place the strip just above where your nostrils flare.
-
Press: Hold the strip down firmly for about 10 seconds, or as long as the package says.
-
Wear: Follow the wear time your brand recommends. Some strips can be worn for up to 12 hours, but remove them sooner if you experience discomfort.
-
Remove: Use warm water to loosen the strip, then peel it off slowly instead of pulling it off dry.
See our full guide on how to apply nasal strips for more placement and removal tips.
Breathe Deeper with Dream Recovery Second Wind Nasal Strips.
Nasal Dilator
Begin by following the fitting instructions from the manufacturer, since cones, rings, and adjustable inserts all fit differently. The dilator should feel secure but not cause pain and discomfort.
-
Choose a size: Use the suggested sizing method or try a trial pack with multiple size options.
-
Insert gently: Wash your hands, then insert the device based on the given instructions. For most designs, the bridge usually sits under the septum between your nostrils.
-
Check comfort: Stop using it if it causes pain, pinching, or bleeding.
-
Clean after use: Wash your nasal dilator with mild soap and water, then rinse, dry, and store it properly.
-
Replace on schedule: Follow the recommended lifespan, and replace the device sooner if it gets soft, changes color, or is damaged.
Never push a device deeper into your nose to keep it in place.
Breathe Easier Either Way With Dream Recovery
Choose what works best for your nose, skin, and daily habits. If you like an external option for workouts, sleep, or when you’re congested, Dream Recovery Second Wind Nasal Strips stay put even when you sweat and use a gentle, hypoallergenic adhesive. Plus, nothing goes inside your nostrils.
If adhesive bothers your skin or you prefer a reusable insert, a nasal dilator may be a better fit. Explore our list of the best nasal dilators for snoring to compare your options.
Ready to try a strip? Shop Second Wind Nasal Strips for easier nasal breathing now.
FAQs
Are nasal dilators more effective than nasal strips?
Sometimes, nasal dilators may be more effective than nasal strips, but not always. A small study found nasal dilators helped with snoring more than strips, but overall research is mixed. Your results depend on fit, your nasal anatomy, and what is causing your snoring.
Can I wear a nasal dilator all the time?
No, you shouldn’t wear a nasal dilator all the time. Follow the wear limits as suggested by the brand. Take it out to clean, and take breaks if your nose gets irritated. If you always need a device to breathe comfortably, you should see a doctor.
Can you use a nasal dilator and a nasal strip together?
Yes, you can usually use a nasal dilator and a strip together, but you should check the instructions for both products first. Using them together might feel helpful, but there is not much evidence that it works better.
Do nasal strips or dilators help with sleep apnea?
Neither is a proven treatment for sleep apnea, but they might help you breathe through your nose alongside your prescribed care. However, they cannot replace CPAP, an oral appliance, or other recommended treatments.
